So the twenty minute method was given up. It didn't suit us and Addie was getting annoyed at the constant pottying. After a week's break we tried a different method.
The three day potty training method is fairly popular in internet land. The people who have tried it promise 3 awful days, but a potty trained kid by the end. The author of the particular ebook that I bought firmly believes that any child from the age of 22 months can be toilet trained.
It it pretty straightforward, once you take your child's nappy off on the first day, it never goes back on again. Not for naps, not for shopping trips, never. They wear big kid [not training] undies. You watch for their wee/poo signs and shove a potty under them as they start. The idea is that they learn to associate the "wee is coming" feeling with the potty, and do their business there.
Day 1 - Addie was great at holding her wee and we caught the poo in the nick of time. The wee never made it in the potty but there were lots of encouraging start stickers to go around. A very exhausting day, but no pain no gain.
Day 2. Lots of catching Addie and putting her in the potty and it resulted in a poo and wee at the same time. Lots of star stickers and telling anyone we could about it. The rest of the day resulted in long wee holding sessions, and big wets on the floor.
Day 3. Not so much wee holding today, and poos in undies. Ewh. The stress is starting to really wear me down and there are tears.
Day 4. Still bravely persisting, but not getting anywhere. Feeling like I'm going insane by staying at home ad watching Addie's bum for 4 days. Lots of wee. Lots of tears [mine still].
Day 5. Make a command decision that this is not going to continue in this manner.
Make no mistake, potty training has not ended, but has morphed. More on that next time.
I think the 3 day method has some wonderful strengths. Addie is showing some great improvement now and I'm sure that the intensive start has helped, but given the combination of our personality types it wasn't fully working for us, despite our best efforts. Addie was at the front door the past two days crying and saying "Car, shoes, pram, shops". We couldn't go anywhere because it would wreck the program. That just doesn't gel for us. She missed her friends, I missed my friends. Tiny was missing out because I was spending every second on Addie and nothing NOTHING was getting done in the house for fear of missing a wee. Its not all doom and gloom and I reckon its a great method for heaps of people, and I learned so much about potty training from it. Stay tuned for part 3!
Read about our first attempt
The Trials of Potty Training here.